Monday, November 16, 2026

Rakuten Mobile's RIC tilts antennas, not economics


Rakuten Mobile reported its third-quarter results on 13 November, and Iain Morris's account in Light Reading the same day is mostly about sites. When Rakuten started out, its executives expected to need 40,000 to 50,000 sites to cover Japan, with simplified radio designs adding 30% to 40% of coverage compared with traditional equipment. It operates 106,000 today, and since KDDI decided in August to end its roaming agreement, Rakuten is building more.

The capex follows. Rakuten's telco business invested about JPY63 billion in 2025 and needs about JPY200 billion this year, of which JPY105.7 billion had been spent by the end of September. The remaining JPY94.3 billion is about 3.3 times what it spent in the final quarter of 2025. Customer additions fell to 297,000 in the quarter from 405,000 a year earlier, which Rakuten blames on concerns about roaming reduction, leaving it with about 11 million customers and a 5% share of the market. Revenue grew 17.1% to JPY111.4 billion and the operating loss narrowed to JPY30.3 billion from JPY37.3 billion, but Light Reading puts the group's cumulative net losses since 2019 at about $7.9 billion.

Rakuten still points to its open RAN. It uses its RAN Intelligent Controller to host software that adjusts antenna tilt without manual intervention, to improve coverage and capacity. Morris notes that the same feature is available from traditional vendors to Japan's other operators, and concludes that virtualization and open RAN have been massively oversold.

I would put it differently. Rakuten proved that a cloud native mobile network, with virtualized RAN, cloud native core, automated operations, etc... can be built and run at national scale, which is what I wrote in 2020, and that part has held. What it did not prove, and was never going to prove, is that software substitutes for spectrum. Rakuten holds 186MHz, about 100MHz of it at 3.5GHz (a poor band for wide area and in-building coverage), against more than 250MHz for SoftBank. No controller recovers the propagation of low-band frequencies an operator does not own.

Automated antenna tilt is not new either. It is a centralized SON function, the ancestor of today's rApps, as mentioned at FYUZ 2 weeks ago. It makes existing sites work better. It does not make a cell reach further than its band allows, and it does not replace a roaming partner who walks away.

In my mind, the 106,000 figure says nothing about whether open RAN works technically. It says the original coverage model rested on an optimistic link budget and on a roaming agreement that would last, and both assumptions were commercial, not architectural. The site count is the cost of spectrum scarcity, and it shows up in the capex line rather than in the architecture diagram. RIC automation delivers real, measurable gains, but they are measured as a percentage of an existing network's performance, not in sites avoided, and the 30% to 40% coverage gain promised 6 years ago was never within a controller's reach.

It will be interesting to see whether Rakuten's next results report the RIC by the coverage it adds, or only by the manual interventions it saves.

AI Gigafactory Northern: Telia brings the fibre


On 16 November, Telia announced it has joined Nokia, British neocloud Nscale, Finnish AI cloud provider Verda and Estonian power systems specialist Skeleton Technologies in a consortium called AI Gigafactory Northern, to bid for the European Commission's AI gigafactory programme. TelecomTV's Ray Le Maistre and Light Reading's Paul Rainford both reported it the same day. The design is federated: facilities in Oulu in Finland, the Tallinn region in Estonia, Valmiera in Latvia and a Swedish site still to be named, with VTT and KTH as research partners.

The Commission aims to mobilise €30 billion across 7 facilities, up to €10 billion from the Commission and national public sources and €20 billion from the private partners in the winning bids. Two thirds of the headline is therefore private money the winners still have to raise, so the €30 billion is a target, not a budget. Bids for large facilities are due on 3 December and for medium ones on 4 February 2027, with winners named in the first half of 2027. Telia joins Telefónica (with the Spanish government and Santander), Orange and Iliad's Scaleway in the AION consortium, Vodafone, linked to a bid with Hochtief, and Deutsche Telekom, still weighing the economics after expanding its own Munich AI factory.

What Telia says it brings is telling: connectivity, data transmission, infrastructure operations and sovereign cloud, through its Telia Cygate integration arm. GPUs are not on the list. This is the role AT&T described for itself last month, fibre and managed connectivity rather than GPU landlord, and I think it is the right one for a mid-sized operator. Telia's balance sheet is not built to carry a large share of €20 billion of private capital, and neoclouds such as Nscale exist to take exactly that risk.

The federated design is where it gets interesting. The consortium says spreading capacity over 4 locations reduces concentration risk, draws on several sources of decarbonised energy and lets it build where power, grid connections, land, cooling, etc... are available. That is sound for energy procurement and resilience. It is less obvious for what a gigafactory is meant to do, which is train very large models. Large training runs want tightly coupled GPUs on a single low latency fabric. Spread them over Oulu, Tallinn and Valmiera and either each site runs its own jobs (in which case the consortium has 4 AI factories, not a gigafactory) or the inter-site network has to behave like a backplane. This is the fabric versus location question I raised in July, and it lands squarely on Telia's part of the bill of materials.

In my mind, that is both the opportunity and the exposure for Telia. If the federated model works, the operator's fibre and operations are what turn 4 buildings into one facility, which is a far more defensible position than renting racks. If it does not, the consortium ends up with a regional inference and sovereign cloud footprint carrying a gigafactory label, which is a reasonable business, just not the one in the Commission's brief. The announcement gives no capacity in MW or GPUs, no split of investment between partners and no design target for inter-site latency, so it is too early to tell which one is being bid.

It will be interesting to see, when the winners are named next year, whether the Commission scores distributed designs like this one as gigafactories or as a collection of AI factories with good fibre.