Showing posts with label Rakuten. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rakuten. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2026

Rakuten Mobile's RIC tilts antennas, not economics


Rakuten Mobile reported its third-quarter results on 13 November, and Iain Morris's account in Light Reading the same day is mostly about sites. When Rakuten started out, its executives expected to need 40,000 to 50,000 sites to cover Japan, with simplified radio designs adding 30% to 40% of coverage compared with traditional equipment. It operates 106,000 today, and since KDDI decided in August to end its roaming agreement, Rakuten is building more.

The capex follows. Rakuten's telco business invested about JPY63 billion in 2025 and needs about JPY200 billion this year, of which JPY105.7 billion had been spent by the end of September. The remaining JPY94.3 billion is about 3.3 times what it spent in the final quarter of 2025. Customer additions fell to 297,000 in the quarter from 405,000 a year earlier, which Rakuten blames on concerns about roaming reduction, leaving it with about 11 million customers and a 5% share of the market. Revenue grew 17.1% to JPY111.4 billion and the operating loss narrowed to JPY30.3 billion from JPY37.3 billion, but Light Reading puts the group's cumulative net losses since 2019 at about $7.9 billion.

Rakuten still points to its open RAN. It uses its RAN Intelligent Controller to host software that adjusts antenna tilt without manual intervention, to improve coverage and capacity. Morris notes that the same feature is available from traditional vendors to Japan's other operators, and concludes that virtualization and open RAN have been massively oversold.

I would put it differently. Rakuten proved that a cloud native mobile network, with virtualized RAN, cloud native core, automated operations, etc... can be built and run at national scale, which is what I wrote in 2020, and that part has held. What it did not prove, and was never going to prove, is that software substitutes for spectrum. Rakuten holds 186MHz, about 100MHz of it at 3.5GHz (a poor band for wide area and in-building coverage), against more than 250MHz for SoftBank. No controller recovers the propagation of low-band frequencies an operator does not own.

Automated antenna tilt is not new either. It is a centralized SON function, the ancestor of today's rApps, as mentioned at FYUZ 2 weeks ago. It makes existing sites work better. It does not make a cell reach further than its band allows, and it does not replace a roaming partner who walks away.

In my mind, the 106,000 figure says nothing about whether open RAN works technically. It says the original coverage model rested on an optimistic link budget and on a roaming agreement that would last, and both assumptions were commercial, not architectural. The site count is the cost of spectrum scarcity, and it shows up in the capex line rather than in the architecture diagram. RIC automation delivers real, measurable gains, but they are measured as a percentage of an existing network's performance, not in sites avoided, and the 30% to 40% coverage gain promised 6 years ago was never within a controller's reach.

It will be interesting to see whether Rakuten's next results report the RIC by the coverage it adds, or only by the manual interventions it saves.

Monday, July 5, 2021

NEC MWC 21 Headlines

Whether you were unable to physically go to Mobile World Congress, or were too busy to catch all the announcements, I figured I would put together a brief overview of what we announced this year.

This is also an excellent explanation to those who have been asking what decided me to come work for NEC. If you read the following, I think you will get a good idea.

Besides working with amazing teams and very smart people, what drawn me to NEC is the continuation of innovation and deployment of open and disaggregated networks I started as an independent analyst at {Core Analysis}, as an executive at Telefonica and as an advisor at Bell Canada.

Our first big announcement was from Vodafone UK, selecting NEC for deployment of our 5G Massive MIMO radio units in the UK. It was promptly followed by Deutsche Telekom announcing NEC 5G open RAN mMIMO in Germany. NEC is proving once again its market leadership in Open RAN with the deployment of Radio Units in dense urban environments at commercial scale. Many vendors have massive MIMO technology, some vendors are Open RAN, we are the first and the only one to have deployed massive MIMO Open RAN in urban networks. This will change and we welcome the competition for this market to grow.

As Open RAN becomes mainstream, the opportunity for cost savings and new savings relies on the optimization of virtual resources. This selection of NEC by NTT DOCOMO to develop their Radio Intelligent Controller (RIC) is another testament of our innovation and pioneering spirit.

To grow, the Open RAN market needs many different configurations, to offer connectivity products for all kinds of environments (public, private, urban, rural, industrial, government...). We did our part announcing 3 new massive MIMO open RAN RUs.

NEC is focusing on providing RUs that are high performance high quality and completely open. We share this philosophy with MTI and that is why we are proud to have announced a strategic partnership with them.

The other important part of Open RAN is the software. NEC has been recognized as a leading solutions integrator of third parties in that space and will continue to do so, but in complement has announced the launch of of its own cloud native high performance open RAN software offering. 5G success depends on a rich ecosystem and an abundance of vendors.


Shifting from Open RAN, 5G's success will be realized through the capacity to create connectivity products that are adapted to the different use cases. A key element for this a core network that is cloud native, capable of being deployed in public or private clouds and that is blazingly fast. We are proud to announce the world fastest 5G Core network deployed in Rakuten's mobile network, in collaboration with Intel. At the same time, we showed off our deployment together with Netcracker on AWS cloud.

Private and enterprise networks are an important part of 5G and we announced our collaboration with NTT data to promote solutions to accelerate its adoption.

By now, you probably understand why I am so humbled to have been invited to join NEC and to support all these products and teams. It is a great privilege to be able to continue contributing to an open, disaggregated, high performance 5G. More to come soon, stay tuned!


Friday, September 18, 2020

Rakuten: the Cloud Native Telco Network

Traditionally, telco network operators have only collaborated in very specific environments; namely standardization and regulatory bodies such as 3GPP, ITU, GSMA...

There are a few examples of partnerships such as Bridge Alliance or BuyIn mostly for procurement purposes. When it comes to technology, integration, product and services development, examples have been rare of one carrier buying another's technology and deploying it in their networks.

It is not so surprising, if we look at how, in many cases, we have seen operators use their venture capital arm to invest in startups that end up rarely being used in their own networks. One has to think that using another operator's technology poses even more challenges.

Open source and network disaggregation, with associations like Facebook's Telecom Infra Project, the Open Networking Foundation (ONF) or the Linux Foundation O-RAN alliance have somewhat changed the nature of the discussions between operators.

It is well understood that the current oligopolistic situation in terms of telco networks suppliers is not sustainable in terms of long term innovation and cost structure. The wound is somewhat self-inflicted, having forced vendors to merge and acquire one another in order to be able to sustain the scale and financial burden of surviving 2+ years procurement processes with drastic SLAs and penalties.

Recently, these trends have started to coalesce, with a renewed interest for operators to start opening up the delivery chain for technology vendors (see open RAN) and willingness to collaborate and jointly explore technology development and productization paths (see some of my efforts at Telefonica with Deutsche Telekom and AT&T on network disaggregation).

At the same time, hyperscalers, unencumbered by regulatory and standardization purview have been able to achieve global scale and dominance in cloud technology and infrastructure. With the recent announcements by AWS, Microsoft and Google, we can see that there is interest and pressure to help network operators achieving cloud nativeness by adopting the hyperscalers models, infrastructure and fabric.

Some operators might feel this is a welcome development (see Telefonica O2 Germany announcing the deployment of Ericsson's packet core on AWS) for specific use cases and competitive environments. 

Many, at the same time are starting to feel the pressure to realize their cloud native ambition but without hyperscalers' help or intervention. I have written many times about how telco cloud networks and their components (Openstack, MANO, ...) have, in my mind, failed to reach that objective. 

One possible guiding light in this industry over the last couple of years has been Rakuten's effort to create, from the ground up, a cloud native telco infrastructure that is able to scale and behave as a cloud, while providing the proverbial telco grade capacity and availability of a traditional network. Many doubted that it could be done - after all, the premise behind building telco clouds in the first place was that public cloud could never be telco grade.

It is now time to accept that it is possible and beneficial to develop telco functions in a cloud native environment.

Rakuten's network demonstrates that it is possible to blend traditional and innovative vendors from the telco and cloud environments to produce a cloud native telco network. The skeptics will say that Rakuten has the luxury of a greenfield network, and that much of its choices would be much harder in a brownfield environment.




The reality is that whether in the radio, the access, or the core, in OSS or BSS, there are vendors now offering cloud native solutions that can be deployed at scale with telco-grade performance. The reality as well is that no all functions and not all elements are cloud native ready. 

Rakuten has taken the pragmatic approach to select from what is available and mature today, identifying gaps with their ideal end state and taking decisive actions to bridge the gaps in future phases.




Between the investment in Altiostar, the acquisition of Innoeye and the joint development of a cloud native 5G Stand Alone Core with NEC, Rakuten has demonstrated vision clarity, execution and commitment to not only be the first cloud native telco, but also to be the premier cloud native telco supplier with its Rakuten Mobile Platform. The latest announcement of a MoU with Telefonica could be a strong market signal that carrieres are ready to collaborate with other carriers in a whole new way.