Showing posts with label broadcast. Show all posts
Showing posts with label broadcast. Show all posts

Friday, September 4, 2015

Video is eating the internet: clouds, codecs and alliances

A couple of news should have caught your attention this week if you are interested the video streaming business.

Amazon Web Services confirmed yesterday the acquisition of Elemental. This is the outcome of a trend that I was highlighting in my SDN / NFV report and workshops for the last year with the creation of specialized clouds. Elemental's products are software based and the company was the first in professional video to offer cloud-based encoding on Amazon EC2 with a PaaS offering. Elemental has been building virtual private clouds on commercial clouds for their clients and was the first to coin the term "Software Defined Video". As Elemental joins AWS, Amazon will be one of the first commercial clouds to offer a global, turnkey, video encoding, workflow, packaging infrastructure in the cloud. Video processing requires specific profiles in a cloud environment and it is not surprising that companies who have cloud assets look at creating cloud slices or segregated virtual environment to manage the processing heavy, latency sensitive service.


The codec war has been on for a long time, and I had previously commented on it. In other news, we have seen Amazon again join Cisco, Google, Intel, Microsoft Mozilla and Netflix in the Alliance for Open Media. This organization's goal is to counter unreasonable claims made by H.265 / HEVC patent holders called HEVC advance who are trying to create a very vague and very expensive licensing agreement for the use of their patents. The group, composed of Dolby, GE, Mitsubishi Electric and Technicolor is trying to enforce a 0.5% fee on any revenue associated with the codec's use. The license fee would apply indiscriminately to all companies who encode, decode, transmit, display HEVC content. If H.265 was to be as successful as H.264, it would account in the future for over 90% of all video streaming traffic and that 0.5% tax would be presumably levied on any content provider, aggregator, APP, web site... HEVC advance could become the most profitable patent pool ever, with 0.5% of the revenues of Google, Facebook or Apple's video business. The group does not stop there and proposes a license fee on devices as well, from smartphones, to tablets, to TVs or anything that has a screen and a video player able to play H.265 videos... Back to the Alliance for Open Media who has decided to counter attack and vows to create a royalty-free next generation video codec. Between Cisco's Thor, Google's VPx and Mozilla Daala, this is a credible effort to counter HEVC advance.


The Streaming Video Alliance, created in 2014 to provide a forum for TV, cable, content owners and service providers to improve the internet video streaming experience welcomes Sky and Time Warner Cable to the group already composed of Alcatel-Lucent, Beamr, CableLabs, Cedexis, Charter Communications, Cisco, Comcast, Conviva, EPIX, Ericsson, FOX Networks, Intel, Irdeto, Korea Telecom, Level 3 Communications, Liberty Global, Limelight Networks, MLB Advanced Media, NeuLion, Nominum, PeerApp, Qwilt, Telecom Italia, Telstra, Ustream, Verizon, Wowza Media Systems and Yahoo!. What is remarkable, here is the variety of the group, where MSOs, vendors, service providers are looking at transparent caching architectures and video metadata handling outside of the standards, to counter specialized video delivery networks such as Apple's, Google's and Netflix'

All in all, video is poised to eat the internet and IBC, starting next week will no doubt bring a lot more exciting announcements. The common denominator, here is that all these companies have identified that encoding, managing, packaging, delivering video well will be a crucial differentiating factor in tomorrow's networks. Domination of only one element of the value chain (codec, network, device...) will guarantee great power in the ecosystem. Will the vertically integrated ecosystems such as Google and Apple yield as operators, distributor and content owners organize themselves? This and much more in my report on video monetization in 2015.

Wednesday, September 3, 2014

Strategies for multiscreen monetization

Pay TV and OTT providers are increasingly difficult to tell apart. Both are engaged in a battle to capture retain our interest. Many multiscreen strategies are being enacted on both sides to secure this $400 billion market.

Cord cutting, cord shaving are becoming familiar risks for MSOs as viewers’ habits change from scheduled to on demand and from linear to binge watching .

MSOs are hesitating between becoming OTT, partnering with them or embracing multiscreen, while OTT are experimenting with new charging models and are trying to secure exclusive rights for original programming.

These strategies and more are being analyzed in my latest white paper, co-written with Booxmedia.

As large OTT providers are helping consumer-viewing habits evolve, there are great opportunities for MSOs and content providers to offer OTT and multiscreen services that will strengthen their brand, expand their reach and grow their customer base.


Cloud TV everywhere emerges as one of the most successful strategies to date for customer acquisition, retention and monetization.  Robust recommendation, content discovery and ad management are keys for monetization of multiscreen.

Monday, July 22, 2013

Pay TV vs. OTT part V: appointment vs. on-demand


The recent emergence of LTE broadcast and eMBMS has prompted many companies to bet much R&D and marketing dollar on the resurgence of the mobile TV model. 

I have trouble believing that many mobile users will be tuning-in "en masse" at regular appointment to watch their favorite show on a mobile device. 
There is nothing wrong with Pay TV, its audience is stable-ish and while most would see OTT services compete for these eyeballs, I see them as a more complementary play. Pay TV is here to stay and I do not see cord cutting as a credible threat in the short term, more cord shaving or cord picking.

Many have been developing and promoting mobile TV models in the past either through broadcast or unicast technologies. The long defunct services from Qualcomm (MediaFLO) and DVB-H should serve as cautionary tales to those who are betting on the next generation of broadcast services. 

Many fail to understand that mobile TV is not attractive to most people in many circumstances. If you are like me, you will watch TV programs, by order of convenience:

  1. When I want, at home, on my PVR (so I can skip the ads)
  2. Live, at home, when it is time sensitive content ( news, sport event, ceremony...)
  3. At a bar, live, when I want to watch sport live with friends or strangers
  4. On a tablet at home (wifi) when I want to watch something else/more than the main screen
  5. On a tablet at hotel /airport (wifi) ...etc... when I want to watch premium content catch up
  6. On a phone / tablet (cellular) if there is no other choice

Don't get me wrong I watch a good amount of video on mobile, just not TV programs. I remember living in Switzerland some 10 years ago and having one of the first video phones
that would perform video calls and stream mobile TV. Past the novelty aspect, no one was watching TV on their phone then, and it wasn't due to network capacity or video quality. Having a video phone then was seriously cool but that did not take away the fact that the TV content I wanted to watch was not available when I wanted to watch it. My Sonyericsson K600 (remember?) joined my first Smartphone (
Philips Ilium, I designed it at Philips) and my first MMS phone (ericsson T68i) in my private museum together with my first PDA (I sent the world's first picture message on a CDMA iPAQ in 2002). 

This is mostly due to the fact that TV is an appointment experience. I like to be comfortable watching TV because I watch only very specific programs. When I sit down to watch TV, I mostly know beforehand what I will watch. The videos I watch on mobile are not necessarily only short form content but I don't mind being interrupted as much because in my mind, it is mostly light entertainment that does not require concentration nor continuity. It is also mostly serendipitous in nature, I do not necessarily plan what I will watch in advance. 
I know that my children and their elder's behavior is similar. They might watch more long form content on their mobile than me but they are mostly not watching TV content. 
While some see broadcast as a means to considerably reduce video load on mobile networks, I think they are missing the point. TV by appointment is a very small portion of the preferred usage, for very specific content, in very specific circumstances. Broadcast TV on mobile makes very little sense apart from niche usage (stadiums,...). 

I don't think that because LTE offers  better network capacity, higher speeds, better quality pictures it will make a better mobile TV service. Don't think for a second that subscribers will pay more than a couple of bucks per month (if anything) to have a TV experience on mobile. People pay for quality, relevance and immediacy on mobile, not the best attributes for broadcast. So before you think about "monetizing" my mobile TV experience, think hard because I won't pay for TV broadcast on mobile.

If you haven't read the other posts in this series, you can find them here for context.
Pay TV vs. OTT:
Part I: The business models
Part II: Managed devices and services vs. OTT
Part III: CE vendors and companion screens
Part IV: Clash of the titans



Tuesday, April 2, 2013

Patrick Lopez to speak at NAB show on cloud adoption




Patrick Lopez to speak at DCIA CLOUD COMPUTING CONFERENCE 
Third Annual Conference at the NAB Show to feature cloud industry experts

Washington, DC – Las Vegas, NV April 02, 2013 – The Distributed Computing Industry Association (www.DCIA.info)  today announced the first wave of speakers to participate in its CLOUD COMPUTING CONFERENCE at the 2013 NAB Show, the third annual DCIA event within the NAB Show, taking place on Monday and Tuesday, April 8th-9th, at the Las Vegas Convention Center in Las Vegas, NV.

“We’re thrilled that our opening keynote speaker will be Amazon Web Services’ Global Digital Media Business Strategy Leader Mark Ramberg; and that our marquee keynotes include Disney’s Program Director, Cloud Hosting, Chris Launey, and IBM’s Lead Partner for Global Business Services, Saul Berman,” said DCIA CEO Marty Lafferty.

“We’re also very pleased to have on our agenda Patrick Lopez, CEO of {Core analysis}  who will speak on Industry Update on Cloud Adoption. How are cloud-based technologies currently being deployed throughout the audio/video ecosystem? ” added Lafferty.

"Cloud computing is an emerging and important trend in the treatment and management of video and audio assets. I am pleased to be participating in such an important event and panel and to share my experience in the adoption of cloud in mobile networks" said Lopez.

CCC at NAB will feature more than seventy speakers in a two-day event track that will demonstrate the new ways cloud-based solutions are providing increased reliability and security, not only for commercial broadcasting and enterprise applications, but also for military and government implementations.

From collaboration during production, to post-production and formatting, to interim storage, delivery, and playback on fixed and mobile devices, to viewership measurement and big-data analytics, cloud computing is having an enormous impact on high-value multimedia distribution.

More information is available at http://bit.ly/Y4wrII and delegates can register to attend at http://bit.ly/TGKgjV.

About the DCIA

The DCIA is an international trade organization, established in 2003, with more than one-hundred industry-leading member companies, including software developers, broadband network operators, and content providers. The DCIA conducts working groups, oversees political initiatives, and publishes the weekly online newsletter DCINFO.

About {Core analysis}

{Core analysis} is a boutique industry analyst practice focusing on the intersection of mobile, video and OTT. The company releases a yearly report on the state of mobile video and presents at influential industry events such as NAB, Informa's mobile video global summit and LTE series.

Media Contacts

Kelly Larabee
+1 410-476-7965

Patrick Lopez
+1 514 823 0314

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

Intel and Samsung partner for open OS in smartphones and connected devices


As you will remember, Intel had decided to leave the connected TV space to ARM back in October, after failing repetitively to gain any significant market share.Its Atom chips failed to convince and deliver a significantly better cost performance ratio to their prospective OEM and ODM.


Samsung told Informa telecoms that they are planning to merge their homegrown operating system BADA with Intel's opensource Tizen. The move will be gradual and will first affect handsets, with low end devices staying on BADA for a while and high end smartphones and tablets moving to Tizen as early as Q2 2012.


Smart TVs should follow shortly there after. 


An interesting move, that allows Samsung to free themselves from the cumbersome Google-Android relationship and to stay clear of the current patent war between OS / app / device vendors.
At the same time, it allows Intel to take a prominent place in one of the fastest growing segments in consumer electronics, connected devices, as we have seen here.

Monday, December 5, 2011

Pay TV vs OTT part IV: clash of the titans

We have reviewed and discussed at length (here, here, and here) the fundamental changes that OTT is causing to the pay TV market. As consumer electronics vendors become content aggregators and as more screens get now directly connected to the internet, there is less and less value in a set top box that is an exclusive managed device from your MSO.

Service providers themselves are ambivalent about the box. It used to be the main tangible asset that MSOs marketed to "own" a subscriber relationship, with a safe environment allowing transactions, access control and digital rights management to monetize live and on demand programs.
Lately, it has looked increasingly like a ball and chain that MSOs have dragged, a costly installed base, slow to evolve and adapt to the latest technologies, incapable of competing against better services and cost structures evolved from OTT.

Microsoft, in the latest incarnation of its XBox Live service, has brokered deals with several dozens of content providers beyond existing Hulu and Netlix and  is launching today. More interestingly, Verizon FiOS, Comcast Xfinity and HBO are also part of the package... as OTT apps. The XBox is already a high-density, high-performance gaming and multimedia environment to play online games and stream video. Adding live TV and VOD makes sense and makes the set top box completely redundant. Microsoft innovates by integrating Bing, its search engine, the Kinect, its haptic motion recognition device and voice, with the EPG (Electronic Programming Guide) of the programmer. You can literally search y voice for a show, an actor, a director and see the results aggregated on your screen from various sources.

While you still have to be a Comcast or Verizon cable subscriber to avail of the services in the states, the writing (or rather the screen) is on the wall.

This experiment will no doubt cast a new light on the 35 million XBox live accounts, putting Microsoft firmly shoulder to shoulder with Google's TV efforts (and Motorola's set top boxes) and the next generation of Apple TV.


Soon will be a time when subscribers will buy access from their ISP independently from aggregation and content. Channels and MSOs will compete across new geographies on unmanaged devices, across unmanaged networks. New generation of apps will enable you to discover, access and curate content from your local media servers, the cloud and your traditional providers and present the result on the screen you elect. There is no technological or logistical barrier any longer. The business model of pay TV, subscription, advertising is undergoing changes of seismic proportions.

Friday, October 14, 2011

Pay TV vs. OTT part II: managed devices and networks vs. OTT

It is really interesting to me to see that as Google acquired Motorola, it has become the market leader in video head end and set top boxes overnight without many hardly noticing. It means in my mind that the previous attempt from Google to invade the pay-TV market will be much stronger the second time around when Google TV will be relaunched.

This market looks just like the mobile market 8 years ago, when device vendors all had proprietary operating systems (this is the case with set top boxes middleware and connected TVs, game consoles, net boxes...) and everyone wanted to "own" the customer.

Managed devices, Managed networks
Pay TV is traditionally delivered through a set top box to a home. Because the set top box has until recently been built upon a service provider specifications,because it was sold, rented or subsidized by the service provider, because the service provider decided what services (PVR, Electronic programming guide, search...) would go into that box, for all these reasons the set top box is seen as a managed device. A managed device runs on a managed network, as opposed to unmanaged network (e.g. the internet).
The network is called managed because the service provider controls the backbone, core and delivery, therefore guaranteeing digital rights integrity to content owners and quality of service to content aggregators and subscribers.

What happened in the last year is that managed devices such as set top boxes have become less and less managed and have offered access to OTT content via the internet. These devices are called hybrid, as they offer both cable/satellite managed services and internet access, together with OTT apps access (Hulu, Netfix...).


Unmanaged devices, OTT

Smartphones, tablets, laptops, game consoles, net boxes, connected TVs have made their appearance.These devices are by definition unmanaged or hybrid, since they are all connected to the internet.

Strategy Analytics predicts that over a billion connected devices will be shipped in the next three years, with managed devices being a very small 20% portion of the total.
This is without counting the billions of smartphone and tablets that will be sold at the same time.

OTT apps are flourishing, offering video content to consumers, without the need for a pay TV subscription, in some cases complementing the current offering (for instance, YouTube fills a need that wasn't properly served by PAY TV services) , in other cases, cannibalizing or replacing traditional Pay TV services (for instance, video on demand from the service provider is seriously threatened by Netflix, Hulu...).
Additionally, the content aggregators whose only channel was TV are now addressing directly the customer through OTT. For instance, HBO, a very successful payTV channel is now offering HBO Go, so that its subscriber can watch live, catch up and on demand programming from connected devices. For the moment, in the US, the consumers have to sign up with Comcast, Time Warner Cable... credentials to get access to the service, so the service provider revenues streams are protected, but nothing prevents HBO to go direct overnight, or to offer its programming outside the US directly to consumers...

We will see in the next post that CE vendors are also joining the fray, and we will examine an interesting new trend: companion screens.

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Google / Moto: your TV is the next battlefield

Goodbye Moto!

many out there look at Google`s acquisition of Motorola as a defensive step to ward off patent trolls and competitors aggressively pursuing Google and Android licensees. With 17,500 granted patents and another 7,500 filed, there has to be some value from Motorola`s pioneering technology in wireless networks. Whether this is worth $10.5B after the cash retained by Motorola remains to be seen.

While this is undoubtedly a key aspect of the transaction, I would like to look at the impact of this acquisition on the mobile and TV market.

Would Google entertain a rebirth of their handset strategy? While the attractiveness of the Android ecosystem is largely as a means to have a more open alternative to Apple`s iStore, nothing prevents Google to look at a more vertical, better experience on Google devices than on the OEMs. Lets not forget additionally, that part of the transaction is Motorola Set-top-box and connected devices business. Motorola, according to a study published by The Multimedia Research Group is ranked worldwide market leader in Video head-end and set top boxes shipments.

Why is that important? The next battle room for video is your TV screen. According to Strategy Analytics, TV industry generates $392Bn per year in revenue, half from advertising, half from subscription, payTV...
These revenue flows back approximately 1/3 to content owners, 1/3 to aggregators and channels, 1/3 to service providers.

The next frontier in TV, is OTT (Over The Top). In an OTT model, content providers and aggregators share the revenues 50/50, with nothing left for the operators. As Samsung, connected TV market leader, has created their vertical environment, with SmartTV, creating essentially an app store and a suite of apps that can run on their connected TVs, set-top-boxes, tablets and phones, I am willing to bet that we will see an Apple TV pretty soon (not the little box that connects your TV to iTunes, an actual Apple branded TV).

From then on, it is not difficult to see that the next OS and app store battlefield will be in your leaving room.

Will Google revive GoogleTV, with a new Android environment that can be ported by Consumer Electronics (CE) giants on their connected TVs, set-top-boxes, tablets and phones?
Will CE vendors choose to use Android, now that Google is also a competitor, with Moto`s acquisition? Or will they try to emulate Samsung and create their closed ecosystem?


I will examine in future posts some of the defensive strategies operators are putting in place to retain some value in this changing ecosystem.
I don`t know you, but for me, it spells interesting times for the future. Let me know your thoughts....

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Mobile video 103: On-deck, off deck, broadcast and unicast

Mobile video, as a technology and market segment, can at times be a little complicated.
Here is simple syllabus, in no particular order of what you need to know to be conversant in mobile video. It is not intended to be exhaustive or very detailed, but rather to provide a knowledge base for those interested in understanding more the market dynamics I address in other posts.


On-deck and off-deck (or over-the top, OTT)
  • On-deck mobile video services are services offered directly by the network operator to their subscribers.
    They usually range from a mix of syndicated/ licensed content from aggregators and media companies (music clips, news segments...) to full mobile TV and VOD services such as live and recorded TV, network PVR and catch up TV, Full movie VOD etc... These services are usually premium services with specific tariff plans put in place by the carrier.
  • Off deck services or content are usually provided by third parties not necessarily affiliated with the carrier. These range from social media (linked in, twitter, Facebook...) to user generated content (YouTube, dailymotion...) and professional content (Disney, Hulu, ESPN...). These services are usually not controlled by the network operator and are usually charged for the transport of the data by the carrier but not the content itself.
On-deck content are premium services and generate an important part of a carrier's revenue.  Most carriers do not have content assets though and end up aggregating and reselling content from media companies. Off-deck services are what is driving mobile data growth today. Facebook, YouTube, Netflix and others start to overwhelm and cannibalize what used to be a good revenue maker for carriers. The concept of dumb pipe has emerged over the last few years. Carriers tryu to recapture mobile data traffic and revenue on-deck to avoid being a "dumb pipe" charging for access, but not the value added content.

Broadcast and Unicast 
  • Broadcast video is the method where the connection between the streaming server and the client is one-to-many. The streaming source is unique and is accessed by many devices. This technology has been used for mobile TV services relying on OMA Bcast, ATSC, MBMS, DVB-H and Mediaflo technologies. 
  • Unicast video is the method where the connection between the streaming server and the client is one-to-one. Each connection is unique and can be adapted to the specific conditions of the device, network, etc... The content, its diffusion, quality, advertising,etc... can be personalized for each target. Unicast is used in many mobile TV and Video on Demand, with RTSP protocol. For many"legacy" (i.e. non-smartphone) devices, it is the only video streaming technology. This method has been implemented in many mobile networks for mobile TV as on-deck service.
Although branded as the next generation mobile TV, broadcast has so far failed in many market. But this is due more to the business model than the technology. With broadcast, users all have access to the same programming, the same ads. Most users will consider paying a nominal monthly fee to get access to a few channels, but this is not where the profits are. Unicast offers an alternative as each stream and program can be tailored to the subscriber need. It is more management overhead, but users are ready to pay a premium for an individualized experience.